Saturday, July 07, 2007

Free Market Will Save the Planet if We Even the Playing Field

Last month Rolling Stone magazine featured Live Earth with stories about the performers and articles about our environment. One of the articles was written by Robert F. Kennedy Jr. discusses how the free market can save our environment by promoting efficiency.

Here is part of the article...

Our last, best hope to stop climate change is the free market itself. There is gold in going green, and the same drive to make a buck that created global warming in the first place can now be harnessed to slow the carbon-based pollution that is overheating the planet.

And green investment will not just enrich a few corporations. We know from past experience that it will strengthen America's economy, not to mention our national security, our economic independence and the effectiveness of our world leadership. During the oil crisis sparked by OPEC in the 1970s, American business and government went into overdrive to promote conservation and develop alternatives to Middle Eastern oil.

Between 1977 and 1985, Detroit boosted the fuel efficiency of its automobiles from eighteen to 27.5 miles per gallon. Oil use shrank by seventeen percent while the economy grew by twenty-seven percent. Even more important, oil imports from the Persian Gulf plunged by eighty-seven percent, breaking the cartel's power over America's economy. Had we stayed the course, we would not have needed to import a single drop of oil from the Middle East after 1986 achieving true energy independence that, in all likelihood, would have enabled us to avoid the devastating attacks of September 11th, as well as both Gulf wars.
Kennedy adds...
The global climate crisis is the result not of an orderly free market, but of a distorted market run amok. A truly free market is the planet's best friend. Free markets promote efficiency. "Efficiency," after all, means the elimination of waste and pollution is waste. The pollution that is catastrophically heating the Earth is the result of market failure; the incapacity of a poorly designed marketplace to place a proper value on an essential asset the atmosphere. That market failure has brought us to the brink of a planet wide environmental collapse.
Kennedy then outlines all of the hidden costs the oil and coal industries receive and concludes (emphasis added)...
If all the hidden costs that Americans currently pay for oil were reflected in the price at the pump, gasoline would cost more than $13 a gallon. In short, taxpayers and consumers are essentially giving the oil industry a subsidy of $10 for every gallon of gas sold in America. If we simply eliminated those subsidies and created a truly free market, renewable sources of energy would beat oil ? as well as nuclear power and coal, which receive equally grotesque subsidies. It is only through these giant subsidies that gasoline has a prayer of competing with alternative sources such as biofuels and wind, which produce energy far more cleanly and efficiently, at far less cost.

5 comments:

The Deplorable Old Bulldog said...

Kennedy's analysis is very shallow; I have seen it several times in a variety of contexts. Similarly, if oil futures were not subject to the world's most regressive capital gains tax energy producers, especially wildcat explorers, would need fewer exploration subsidies, increasing supply and driving down prices.

However, his ultimate point is correct that more environmentally friendly industries have major profit making potential. Unfortunately, the most important of these industries is the American auto industry. They are so strapped for cash because 35-year-old labor contracts and 20-year-old marketing strategies are strangling them. This problem has no easy answer either.

If we just force them to start converting assembly lines for higher mileage cars, they really might go under and that would be a catastrophe. Of course, subsidizing automakers gags most people, including most Rs who are opposed to corporate welfare so that doesn’t seem like the best road to follow .

Here's a thought, let's phase out the capital gains tax over 10 years with auto makers and utility companies being the first industries to lose the cap gains tax? That might provide the necessary capital for retooling and building new energy infrastructure without the need for tax dollars and f***ed up government bureaucrats (who really are worse than corporate bureaucrats, although the margin continues to narrow) being involved in the market process.

Old people living on investments would make a killing because of higher profits and bigger dividends, as just a bonus.

AmPowerBlog said...

Kennedy's argument is a sneaky, back door attack on market, in fact. Markets are overregulated as it is. We're far from the ideal Smithian invisible hand. But by attacking markets, Kennedy can have his day attacking "big oil," the "special interests," and any other economic interest organized on the basis of profit rather than altruism.

Nice post!

noneed4thneed said...

Sporer-

You forgot to mention that the US auto industry is burdened by rising health care costs in the US when companies in other countries can focus on making quality products and making a profit. Instead, Detroit has to do that and try and provide health insurance when that isn't their business to do so.

noneed4thneed said...

Donald-

Same can be said for so-called Free Trade. If it was really free trade the agreement would easily fit on 1 page. Instead it is pages and pages long. There is nothing free about it.

Anonymous said...

The free market is always superior to top down government and political actions.

We are very pleased to announce the creation of The Free Market Hall of Fame where members of the Freedom Movement will have the opportunity to initially vote on individuals contributing most to the success and advancement of free markets and free people around the globe during 2007.

Nominations for the Free-Market Hall of Fame are open to the public and can be made by anyone by e-mailing ron@freedomfest.com Individuals can vote for or nominate individuals who they believe should be in the Free Market Hall of Fame. Write-ins are permitted.

The categories will include the following:

1. Academic economists
2. Journalists and writers
3. Business leaders
4. Legislators and government officials
5. Think tanks

A select group of economists and other free-market supporters will make the final decision and vote on upcoming Hall of Fame members.

For more information on the Free Market Hall of Fame go to http://www.freedomfest.com/hofhome.htm

“It’s time we honored all the great teachers, writers, business leaders, legislators, and think tanks that have advanced the cause of liberty," Mark Skousen

Ron Holland, Editor
FreedomFest News http://www.freedomfest.com/news.htm
Author of the online book: “The Swiss Preserve Solution”.